Friday, December 2, 2011

Prosecutorial Discretion Demystified

As many people have heard by now, the Director of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) issued two new memoranda in June of this year encouraging the expanded use of prosecutorial discretion by ICE officers, agents, and attorneys in all phases of civil immigration enforcement. In a nutshell, the new policy is aimed at moving prosecutorial discretion exercised by immigration enforcement officials away from an ad hoc system to a system that focuses government resources on only pursuing high priority cases—criminal aliens, national security threats, repeat immigration violators, and recent border entrants—and setting aside, closing or not initiating cases that are low priority.

The rationale is that government spending on cases that fall outside the enforcement priorities actually hinders the government’s public safety mission by clogging the immigration court dockets and diverting resources away from high priority individuals.
These memoranda announce substantial and, in my opinion, very positive positive policy changes that all immigrants—and their advocates—should be aware of. However, it has also confused many immigrants and citizens alike.
First of all, this new policy does not confer any lawful status on any non-citizen. Thus it is a far cry from amnesty. It will merely result in an indefinite reprieve for certain individuals who are already facing deportation but who are a low enforcement priority.
Second, there is no affirmative right created by this policy. In other words, someone who is undocumented cannot apply for the exercise of discretion. In fact, if you are undocumented or out of status and you surrender yourself and seek prosecutorial discretion it is very likely you will be placed in removal proceedings where you run a serious risk of being deported. In order to benefit from this policy you must be in removal proceedings already, or be very close to being placed in removal proceedings, for prosecutorial discretion to even apply.

Third, there is no enforceable right to appeal a negative prosecutorial discretion decision, though a good immigration lawyer should be able to utilize an informal appeal process by going up the chain of command within the enforcing agency.

Fourth, depending on the case, there could be a potential benefit linked to the exercise of prosecutorial discretion, such as the availability of employment authorization.

Now, in order to implement these new priorities, on August 18, 2011, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) announced a review of all pending removal cases in order to identify those cases that reflect a high enforcement priority for DHS. Drum roll please. According to DHS, the highest enforcement priorities, meaning those that should generally be pursued in an accelerated manner involve a noncitizen:

  • who is a suspected terrorist or national security risk;
  • who has a conviction for—
    - a felony or multiple misdemeanors,
    illegal entry, re-entry, or immigration fraud, or
    a misdemeanor violation involving—
    - violence, threats, or assault,
    - sexual abuse or exploitation,
    - driving under the influence of alcohol or drugs,
    - flight from the scene of an accident,
    - drug distribution or trafficking, or
    - other significant threat to public safety;
  • who is a gang member, human rights violator, or other clear threat to public safety;
  • who entered the country illegally or violated the terms of their admission with the last 3 years;
  • who has previously been removed from the country;
  • who has been found by an immigration officer or immigration judge to have committed immigration fraud; or
  • who otherwise has an egregious record of immigration violations.

  • In contrast, the lowest priority cases—those that should be carefully considered for prosecutorial discretion on a case-by-case basis, involve a noncitizen:
  • who is a member in good standing of the U.S. military, honorably discharged veteran, or the spouse or child of such member or veteran;
  • who is a child, has been in the U.S. for more than 5 years, and is either in school or has successfully completed high school;
  • who came to the U.S. under the age of 16, has been in the U.S. for more than 5 years, has completed high school, and is now pursuing or has successfully completed higher education in the U.S. [yes, this is targeting Dream Act kids]
  • who is over the age of 65 and has been present in the U.S. for more than 10 years;
  • who is a victim of domestic violence in the U.S., human trafficking to the U.S.; or of any other serious crime in the U.S. [this is a particularly big deal];
  • who has been a lawful permanent resident for 10 years or more and has a single, minor conviction for a non-violent offense;
  • who suffers from a serious mental or physical condition that would require significant mental or detention resources; or
  • who has a very long-term presence in the U.S., has an immediate family member who is a U.S. citizen, and has established compelling ties and made compelling contributions to the U.S.
  • In addition to these enforcement priorities, one of the big two prosecutorial discretion memos that came out over the summer makes clear that it is generally against ICE policy to initiate removal proceedings against victims or witnesses to a crime, or to "remove individuals in the midst of a legitimate effort to protect their civil rights or civil liberties."  The language used here is expansive and is designed to protect those involved in labor, housing or similar disputes that are being fought outside of court.  This will hopfeully go a long way to removing the fear of retaliation and removal that noncitizens face when deciding whether or not to speak up and defend their rights.

    Noncitizens who are in removal proceedings or who are worried they are about to be placed in removal proceedings should talk with their immigration lawyer about the possibility of prosecutorial discretion, among other options. Often, it will be a last resort, but it may still be better than the alternative—if the alternative is deportation.



    1. Great Post. Its the best blog and a quality source to get updated by some of the greatest facts,thanks

      tax problems laguna niguel

      1. nice article...

        Obat Bius | Obat Bius Wanita | Jual Obat Bius

        thank you for the information regards success only father / mother

    2. Thanks for the information, sir! Immigration is a tricky field of law to work in, and I commend you for it!
      - New Jersey Lawyer

    3. The mind broken baby lawyer must have assisted thousands of damaged people. They know how to examine wrongful death claims.

      car accident milwaukee

    4. Thanks for sharing and hope your next post will be even better.
      immigration lawyers in Chicago

    5. Nice update it is. Thanks for keeping inform us about the different parts of law via you blog. Immigration Lawyers in Seattle

    6. Very nice! I really enjoyed your blog throughout all the time I have spent on it! thanks for sharing such an informative and nice blog with. I am really aknowleged by the content provided by you on this blog.
      immigration attorney

    7. Adjustment of status,after marriage in USA on a non-immigrant visa, the foreign spouse must show that he or she had originally intended to return home, and the marriage and desire to stay in the United States was not premeditated.

    8. What's gonna happened to those Asian woman who got married in US with an American citizen man and then left the him without any word? They are now not legally separated for almost 5 years and the Asian has not left the country with the span of years and they are not even seeing each other til now. The man has been asking the family of the woman to see him so she won't become an alien to the place? I'm just hearing this kind of story from a friend. I hope you could me find the answers. Thanks! Immigration Lawyers Mississauga

    9. Commercial Real Estate closings is the major part we solve most of the time. We assist individuals and businesses with their legal needs in areas of Residential & Commercial Real Estate closings, Family Law, Immigration Law, Business Law, Wills & Estates and all kinds of Notary Services.

    10. migrants law is a requirement nowadays individuals has to go to other to generate breads and butter thanks for publishing about this topic.

      And if your in a law firm, immigration law and law firm marketing that needs more local customers and pre-qualified prospects, then contact Immigration Law Firm Online Lead Generation Service an Immigration Law Firm Lead Generating Website that will help you increase your local internet leads on any of your local legal marketing,marketing project and freelance immigration law and creates a stylish conversion optimized website for your Immigration Law Firm business, designed to generate IMMIGRATION LAW FIRM LEADS, while optimized to help you rank on the first page of Google.

    11. Thanx for sharing such an informative information. also provides different servies.

      1. The first thing you should think about while hiring a Los Angeles Immigration lawyer is that the range of services they offer you, as there are a number of aspects of the legal system of U.S.

    12. Thanks for sharing this info, it really helped. I think I should probably look into getting a good immigration lawyer in Grand Rapids. We've had some issues that need to be resolved, do you have any suggestions?

    13. The matter that you provide is worth our time and energy.
      Benjamin Yu dui lawyer

    14. Thanks for sharing this information! I have been looking into edmonton immigration lawyers and how they can help me! Can you tell me where I can find more information like this? Thanks so much for sharing!

    15. When you talk to your insurance before signing the policy, all is covered. When you are in trouble, you get Denied Insurance Claims. Do not stay in the dark, insurance companies are known to play with ambiguity, ask help from professionals.
      Denied Insurance Claims

    16. Excellent post.I want to thank you for this informative read, I really appreciate sharing this great post. Keep up your work. immigration lawyer jacksonville fl

    17. Hi there, nice post. This is an interesting and very informative topic. Thanks for sharing you thoughts on this issue. Keep it up, looking forward to read another one in the future. Cheers!

      boston lawyer

    18. Hii..
      It shows that finally at least some members of Congress realize that we can’t ignore the reality of , many of whom this country relies on for its agricultural needs, many of whom came illegally as minors, and many of whom we have already educated but don’t allow to fully participate in our economy.
      Family Law Attorney 32801

    19. It’s a classic great for me to go to this blog site, it offers helpful suggestions New York Arraignment Lawyer

    20. Nicest information!!! I'll be enchanted to greatly help due to what I've learnt from here.Maxcan Visa

    21. I am all time fond of reading the blog, when I reached to this blog I wondered to read such informative article, it inspired me a lot thanks. Solicitate

    22. Great Blog!!! Thanks for sharing the info about Immigration Lawyer. Actually
      Immigration law refers to national government policies which control the phenomenon of immigration to their country.
      immigration lawyers in Phoenix